A cewar Dokar Sturgeon, kashi 90% na shara. Wannan doka Theodoro Sturgeon ne yayi maganarsa lokacin da yake kare almara na kimiyya a cikin shekarun XNUMX.
Wannan dokar ita ce wanda aka ambata a tsakiyar muhawara a Edinburgh International Book Fair akan wata tambaya wacce tayi kwanaki 10 tana mamaye tattaunawar kuma wannan shine mai zuwa: yadda ake fassara almarar kirkirarrun samari ko YA. Duk da naci da yawan wannan tattaunawar, wacce ta ƙunshi Frances Hardinge, Marcus Sedgwick da Simon Mayo, babu wanda ya ji daɗin yadda za a ayyana shi, har ma mawallafin da ke rubuta irin waɗannan littattafan.
Babbar muhawara game da wallafe-wallafen YA a ranar Litinin a wannan bikin ya nuna mummunar hanyar zuwa duk wata muhawara kan yadda za a ayyana adabin YA, batun da a koyaushe yake karkacewa duk lokacin da ya bayyana. Shin Littattafan Matasan Manyan Al'adu ne ko Nau'i? Wanene ke cinye irin wannan adabin? Ka girma da yawa? Ba a rubuta ba?
Matashin Marubucin Marubuci Anthony McGowan ya ambata Dokar Sturgeon da aka bayyana a baya: "90% na adabin Matasa Adut ba su da kyau." Marubucin ya yi tsokaci game da yin nadamar yin magana da masu sauraron al'adar fararen mata a taron YA. A sakamakon haka, wasu sun yi sharhi cewa yawancin masu rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo na Matasan manya mata ne kuma duk masu buga waɗannan littattafan mata ne.
"Akwai adadi mai yawa na makamashi da ke shiga cikin irin waɗannan labaran., labaran da zasu iya jan hankalin mata daga shekaru 20 zuwa 30 maimakon samari. Muna da wannan duniyar da ke mamaye da mata waɗanda ke rubuta waɗannan labaran don sauran 'yan mata su karanta su yi tunani a kansu. "
Matasa Ba zai iya zama nau'in salo ba, a zahiri ba zan ɗauka hakan ba saboda yana daga cikin rukuni inda zai taimaka muku sanin wane irin masu sauraro ne aka nufa. Koyaya, muhawarar, ta bin wannan layi, ya rikide zuwa wasu muhawara da galibi ke faruwa game da wannan nau'in.
McGowan yana bayani ne a kan wani abu da Elizabeth Wein da Philip Womack ba su yarda da shi ba, kuma hakan shi ne, bisa ga abin da ya ambata, baya tunanin manya su karanta adabin Matasa.
“Ina ganin ya kamata ku ci gaba da karanta Tolstoy da Dostoevsky ko Dickens kuma ku daina karanta Crespúscuo da Wasannin Yunwa. Yana daga cikin zama balagaggu ka bar wadannan abubuwan a baya. "
Da dama daga cikin wadanda suka halarci taron sun koka game da wannan kin amincewa da adabin Matasan da ke cikin manya. Marubuciya Patrice Lawrence, mai shekaru 49, ta sanar da tafawa cewa ba zai bata lokaci ba wajen karanta Dostoevsky da Tolstoy saboda kawai baya son karanta su. Wasu kuma sunyi tsokaci akan hakan an canza hanyar muhawara gaba daya mantawa da ma'anar abin da adabin Matasa ya ke.
Yawancin marubutan wannan adabin yaba girman jaririn samarin su a sauran muhawara, ya kara da cewa ba su suka rubuta wadannan labaran ba musamman don wannan masu sauraro. Marubuciya Jenny Downham tayi tsokaci a tattaunawar cewa hNa ga littafinsa, Kafin In Mutu, a cikin bangarorin Adan Matasa da manyaHaka ne, wanda ya zama wawanci a gareshi, amma a matsayin ra'ayin tallan baiyi kyau ba.
A matsayina na mai karatun Matasan Matasa ina mamakin dalilin da yasa koyaushe kuke rarrabasu kuma kuke tunanin cewa kowane mutum yakamata yayi karatu gwargwadon shekarunsa. Littattafai na nishadi ne kuma idan kun nishadantar da ku da litattafan da ba '' shekarunku '' ba, ban ga wata illa ba. A wannan bangaren Ba za a iya karanta kowane irin littattafai ba? Baya ga karatun Matasa Na ke son karanta wasu nau'ikan littattafan rukunin manya kuma na yi imanin cewa duka rukunonin na iya ba da gudummawa sosai ga kowane nau'in masu karatu, duk ya dogara da sanin yadda za a zaɓi littafin da ya dace.