The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs

The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs

In recent years the historical novel has been the preferred subject of many readers, from The name of the rose but also The pillars of the earth, plots with medieval and historical background have stood out on the shelves of many libraries and bookstores. The last work that in addition to being a historical novel is a scientific reference work is called The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs. A work that collects the misfortunes of the five sons of the Catholic Monarchs, their destinies and the role that their lives played in the Modern History of Europe and Spain.

Over the past few years, many writers have decided to create and tell stories about the Catholic Monarchs, the last of these has been Vicenta Marquez de la Plata, a writer of the historical novel who has wanted to tell the tragic life of the children of the Catholic Monarchs since they are in one way or another the ones who have transmitted the wishes of their parents.

In addition, Vicenta Márquez has chosen some princes or rather infants, since in Spain only the term “prince”For the heir to the throne, very prone to the novel and fictitious stories since all the children of the Catholic Monarchs they had life cut short.

Vicenta María Márquez de la Plata, the author, is a historian and a graduate in Genealogy, Heraldry and Nobility from the CSIC Institute. She has been a professor at the Modern University of Lisbon and the University of Seville. Although his specialty is the late medieval period, Vicenta has had very successful forays into other eras of history, as evidenced by The tragic fate of the children of the Catholic Monarchs or his most recent work, The Valid.

According to Spanish tradition, there can only be one prince and the rest of the aspirants to the throne are called Infantes

Deaths, unhappy marriages, illnesses, etc…. Many topics that focused on the children of Isabel and Fernando and that strongly truncated the lives of these infants and the premature Spanish state.

We all know the love story of Joan the Crazy, which Vicenta Márquez de la Plata has great interest and accuracy in her work "The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs”, But few know the tragic story of young prince John or how Catherine, their sister, was queen of England and the first wife of Henry VIII, the first monarch to divorce and who institutionalized divorce among Christians.

These may be the children of the Catholic Monarchs who most influenced the course of History. With the death of Juan, the Trastamara dynasty, to which the Catholic Monarchs belonged and was a local dynasty, came to an end and this meant the government of a young Spanish Empire by foreign rulers to the Iberian Peninsula.

Juan was born in the campaign against the Conquest of the Kingdom of GranadaHis parents longed for a male child that at the moment they did not have and by having Juan, not only the Catholic Monarchs but also the entire kingdoms placed their hopes on this young prince.

Juan married the sister of Felipe el Hermoso, unlike Juana la Loca, Juan and his wife loved each other and it was love at first sight, but Juan's fragile health truncated the destiny of this marriage and without having finished the honeymoon, Juan died taking I get the hopes of Spain.
The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs

Catalina's role was clearer or rather, more direct. As the wife of Henry VIII, Catherine was Queen of England and their marriage was perhaps the first dynastic problem about crowns and inheritance in the Modern Age, problems that were born already with the preparation of the wedding.

Pedro Mártir de Anglería: «Here lies the hope of Spain».

Paradoxical was the fact that the person who initiated the end of Catalina was also of Spanish origin. We all know what happened between Anne Boleyn, Henry VIII and their unfortunate wife Catherine. A trio that not only revolutionized the country but also the religions of the moment, especially the Catholic Christian religion.

La unfortunate love story of Juana La Loca We all know it, either from our History classes or from the famous movie of the same name. Unlike her siblings, Juana was not the victim of death but the death of her relatives. Felipe el Hermoso, son of the Austrian emperors and Juana's crazy love, suffered the visit of death very soon and this triggered the madness of Juana, who already had several children of the Burgundian prince and who would be the future rulers of the Spanish Empire and the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Juana was quickly paired with the young Austro-Hungarian prince who according to the Catholic Monarchs would mean a rapprochement between Spain and the Central European kingdoms. Although this marriage was arranged, the love between Juana and Felipe was very passionate and crazy, something that would bring serious consequences.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ND7cOLp7lk0

More unnoticed the fate of Ms. Maria y ElizabethInfantas of Spain and queens of Portugal, first it was Doña Isabel who married the Portuguese king and after her death it was Doña María who took her place as wife and queen of Portugal. And it is perhaps this lack of awareness that is unfair about his story. Both the links of María and those of Isabel represented a significant change in the Modern History of Spain. These unions allowed the great-grandson of the Catholic Monarchs, Felipe II, to be king of Portugal and Spain, thus uniting for the first time in a long time the entire Iberian Peninsula under the same monarch.

It was the grandchildren and not the children of the Catholic Monarchs who had a crown

Of course the children of the Catholic Monarchs had the very marked and very truncated lives, as if Machiavelli himself had written them, although to tell the truth, the great author wrote his work "The Prince”In honor of his father, King Ferdinand the Catholic.

The tragic fate of the Children of the Catholic Monarchs is a historical work that although with some literary licenses, their data, their stories, their knowledge are true. This makes the work a good summary of what happened in Spain or the Spains (as the inhabitants of the time called it) between 1495 and 1504, the year in which Isabel la Católica died and in which only one daughter lived. of the Catholic Monarchs, Juana, better known as Juana la loca.

Possibly I would have preferred that Vicenta Márquez de la Plata had been more ambitious and had spoken something about the descendants of the children of the Catholic Monarchs, I am not referring to the way he mentions them in the work but to give them a more leading role, not in vain, Mary of Tudor, daughter of Catherine and Henry VIII and Charles of Ghent, son of Juana and Felipe el Hermoso, were kings of England and Spain respectively. Titles obtained by the grandchildren but not obtained by the children of the Catholic Monarchs. Even so, the work presented to us by Vicenta Mª Márquez de la Plata is an exceptional work that may well be valid for our literary moments or for our scholarly moments, since in both moments the work is very good. So if you are lovers of historical novels or history, keep this work in mind and if you see that you are interested in reading it, it is something that costs nothing.

Important issues

  • El reign of the Catholic Monarchs it was from the year 1479 to the year 1504 (death of Isabel la Católica).
  • The children of the Catholic Monarchs were 5: Isabel, Catalina, María, Juana and Juan.
  • The only son who succeeded the Catholic Monarchs was Juana, who she never ruled because she was crazy although she has the title of Queen of Castile.
  • In 1504 Isabel the Catholic dies and in 1516 Fernando el Católico, after which the regency of Cardinal Cisneros appears.
  • With the Catholic Monarchs the concept of «Spain»Where each kingdom maintained its autonomy.

To know more….

  • Ortiz, Alonzo (1983):Dialogue on the education of Prince Don Juan, Son of the Catholic Monarchs. José Porruá Turanzas Editions, Madrid.
  • Hickling Prescott, W. and Val Valdivieso Mª. I. of, (2004): History of the Catholic Monarchs. Castile and Leon.
  • Val Valdivieso Mª. I. of,(2004): Isabel I of Castile (1451-1504). Editions of the Orto, Madrid.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

*

*

  1. Responsible for the data: Miguel Ángel Gatón
  2. Purpose of the data: Control SPAM, comment management.
  3. Legitimation: Your consent
  4. Communication of the data: The data will not be communicated to third parties except by legal obligation.
  5. Data storage: Database hosted by Occentus Networks (EU)
  6. Rights: At any time you can limit, recover and delete your information.

  1.   late said

    Articulazo! great the review with the historical complement 🙂

  2.   Villamandos said

    It's nice to read articles like this one.

    Congratulations friend!

  3.   Michael Gaton said

    The truth is that the book looks very good. I have always found it regrettable how little historical culture people have on transcendental issues in the history of Spain.

    Now the life of the children of the Catholic Monarchs is better known, but above all thanks to the success of Isabel, the series broadcast by TVE1.

    Regards,

    1.    Joaquin Garcia said

      The truth is that before Isabel there were other series that well illustrated the lives of the children of the Catholic Monarchs, such as Los Tudors. I hope that little by little more series of this style will come out. Greetings and thanks for the comment!!! 😉

  4.   Eva Maria Rodriguez said

    Added to my to-read list, and more after an introduction like this.

  5.   Carmen Guillen said

    Look that it is difficult for a historical article to catch me and read it in full (personal tastes), but you have achieved it Joaquin. A very good and comprehensive article. !! Congratulations!!

    1.    Joaquin Garcia said

      Thank you very much Carmen, although your articles tend to catch me a lot. Regards, and thank you very much. 😉

  6.   Nacho said

    Thank you very much for this fantastic article! I put it on my list of books to read.

  7.   Luis said

    What an introduction… I'm putting it on my pending reading list.

  8.   ignaciolasala said

    I just updated my to-do list putting this one first. It looks so good.

  9.   gnzl said

    I agree with the rest of the comments, a very complete article.

  10.   yabier said

    I'm not a big fan of the historical novel, which I put aside years ago, but the article is very well done and from what you comment, the book reviewed does not seem like the classic fictional vendeburras hoax.

    To take advantage of the comment and recommend something related to the theme of heirs to the throne, but of a more fantastic kind, I leave you the clue of a very curious short novel called 'El amigo de la muerte', written by Pedro Antonio de Alarcón, one of our romantics.

    http://www.cervantesvirtual.com/obra-visor/el-amigo-de-la-muerte-cuento-fantastico–0/html/ff8e4904-82b1-11df-acc7-002185ce6064_1.html

    1.    Joaquin Garcia said

      Thank you Yabier, for the comment and for the contribution. You have given me an idea and it is that it may be time to review the classics in ALiterature. Thank you very much 😉

  11.   Without tilde said

    Thanks for the article, interesting interesting

  12.   anavaldespastor said

    I love the article. But I have a question about Juana La loca. You say he went mad after Felipe's death. But didn't Felipe himself lock her up when the Cortes refused to incapacitate her? It is that it is not so clear that she was ill, but that she threw a tremendous fight out of jealousy. Well, I understood it that way. In any case, I love the article and am looking forward to reading the book already. Thanks for sharing!

    1.    Joaquin Garcia said

      Hello Ana, the case of Juana la Loca is somewhat confusing, not only for the time but for History in general. The Cortes refused to incapacitate her, but Felipe did not get to swear the Cortes, so I really don't know to what extent it was an anecdote, to what extent it was reality and to what extent it affected Spain, because it could. lock up but a few hours or a few days. What if it is known that before Felipe's death, Juana did not show signs of insanity (what we understand today as insanity) and after Felipe's death she did show them. Even with everything, Juana received the title of Queen of Castile, but she never served as such, even after the revolts of the Comuneros. By this I mean that it is a very confusing figure as you will see. By the way, thank you very much for your comment and for the compliments. All the best;)

      1.    anavaldespastor said

        Thanks Joaquin!

  13.   Ascen Jiménez (@ AscenJimnez1) said

    Very interesting. We will have to read it! 😉

  14.   Fran Marin said

    I had heard of this book, and now I think I have decided to read it! Thanks for the information and very good page!

  15.   Joaquin Garcia said

    Thank you all very much for your opinions and thanks and, of course, for your doubts, I hope you like the book and that you tell it here, if you don't like it too. And of course, if you can, I would appreciate it if you include something about the book of your harvest, so future readers can have a more complete view of the book. Thank you all once again. Greetings 😉

  16.   mayrafdezjoglar said

    This book falls flat !! Although it is a shame that some children are so famous and others go unnoticed like María who, even if only for having had 10 children, already deserves her place in history. We all know that Juana was the mother of Carlos I but no one remembers that Maria was the mother of Isabel de Portugal, wife of Carlos I and empress of the Holy Empire.

  17.   Jesus Alvarez said

    Excellent article, Joaquin. I have been a great fan of the historical novel for many years. I write down the book. Just reading your article makes you want to start reading it. Thanks also for the comments, really interesting.

  18.   nati said

    Where could i buy the book

  19.   javier urbasos arbeloa said

    Juan was born in Seville but during the Castilian civil war campaign between Isabel and Juana la beltraneja.